The Ventura County Star reported today that Simi Valley Mayor Paul Miller would send the United Church of Christ in Simi Valley a bill for nearly $40,000 for protests that took place near the church this weekend.
The church has been “harboring an illegal immigrant,” according to Miller. The immigrant is identified in the report only as “Liliana.” The mayor and the city council are apparently angry that despite their having warned Rev. June Goudy in August not to take in Liliana, she defied them.
The mayor’s and city council’s actions are clearly unconstitutional. Goudy should hire a lawyer and contest the fine. She will prevail in court.
A similar incident occurred in San Bernardino this spring after the City of San Bernardino billed Armando Navarro, organizer of a peaceful antiwar and pro-immigration rally, $17,674.08 for their policing of the event.

In this case, the city’s sensible mayor, Patrick Morris, who served for 30 years as a Superior Court judge, was strongly opposed to the fine, saying in a May 17 e-mail that “The right to free speech, especially when it involves criticism of our government, is one of our most cherished individual rights as Americans.”
“This fundamental right cannot and should not be burdened with the concern or fear that if you exercise your right to free speech, you will be sent a bill by your government.”

The irony is that most of the protesters were from an inane and mean-spirited group, Save Our State, which was picketing the church in protest of its protection of Liliana.
The problem with these organizations and the politicians that support their point of view, like Miller and Congressman Elton Gallegly, is that they focus only on the problem of illegal immigration and turn a blind eye to less talked about values that made our country great: tolerance, hospitality to foreigners, compassion, and charity.
They forget, perhaps, that their own ancestors were immigrants too, albeit probably legal immigrants, but with the same
desire to live in freedom and prosperity.
Instead of taking a humane approach to the problem of illegal immigration, politicians and anti-immigration activists and their supporters instead focus on its negative aspects, notably those few individuals who commit crimes.
Gallegly’s recent editorial in the Ventura County Star is a prime example of this intolerance.
The United States has both the right and obligation to enforce its own immigration laws. But we should not lose the soul of the nation in the process.
In the end, Liliana, if she is an illegal immigrant, would have to be deported. This is a sad and an avoidable consequence of her decision to cross the border illegally.
It is avoidable because we can change our laws to allow guest workers. Our economy demands such a change, but the mainstream of the Republican Party cannot seem to get its act together and support the idea.
It may be that Miller, who has had a long career in law enforcement prior to becoming mayor, does not understand that his actions are illegal under the Constitution. Perhaps he is blinded by his anger at having the resources of his officers tied up by an inconvenient protest, caused by the actions of a person he disagrees with.
I’d like to give him the benefit of the doubt.
But it is more likely that Miller knows exactly what he is doing. It seems that he is using his political office not for the good of the community, but to advance his cynical political agenda by whatever means are at hand.
“This city is not going to be known as ’sanctuary city,’” Miller said, according to the Ventura County Star.
He will not win this fight.
Links:
“Church to Be Billed for Costs of Protest,” by Anna Bakalis, Ventura County Star, September 19, 2007.
“Mayor: City Was Wrong to Bill Protesters,” by Robert Rogers, SBUSN.com, May 18, 2007.
“Controlling Public Protest: First Amendment Implications,” by Daniel L. Schofield, Unit Chief of the Legal Instruction Unit at the FBI Academy, Law Enforcement Bulletin, November 1994.
Patrick Morris’s Superb E-Mail